Tuesday, May 4, 2010

Opinion - Due Tuesday May 11th

Do you think that Roy did the right thing getting Dana in trouble on purpose? Why do you think he did it? Give evidence to support both answers.

23 comments:

  1. I think Roy did the right thing to do to Dana by leading him to the construction site to find the ciggaretts because it was for self defense and to teach Dana a lesson. Roy was insualting Dana and runing until Roy purposely slowed down and told Dana there were ciggaretts in the trailer at the construction site. Then Dana went up to the trailer and triggered the mouse traps. After that Dana got introuble with curly and Officer Delinko. E.O.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think Roy did the right thing by getting Dana in trouble because Dana disverved it because of all of the not right things he did to Roy. I think Roy got Dana in trouble because he did not want the police to capture Mullet Fingers. Some evidence to support it is that Mullet Fingers mom and dad will send him back to school if they find out he's here. Some evidence for the other answer is that Dana tried to almost kill Roy so why wouldn't Roy get revenge.

    Logan K.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think roy did not do the right thing because it got him in big trouble.
    he might get charged.
    HE might get a ticket for doing it and it was not him. RJ

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think Roy did not do the right thing by getting Dana in trouble because he could've handled that situation better,without lying. For example, he could have told Dana he did not like getting beat up and that Dana should stop. I think Roy did that because if he didn't bribe Dana then he would have probably gotten beat up.

    Christal S.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think roy did the right thing getting Dana in trouble because Dana would NOT leave Roy alone and Roy had to do something because otherwise the school wouldnt have done anything and nor would his parents. I think Roy did it to get Dana to leave him alone for once and so that Roy could try an save the owls without having to worry about Dana, and also, Roy doesnt want to get in anymore trouble so if Dana isnt around, Roy wont have to worry about him.
    Lauren

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think Roy did not do the right thing because even though Dana bullies him Roy shouldn't sink to his level. I think Roy did do it though, because he just wanted to get it over with. An example is when he mooned him because why would he do that anyway? He obviously was sick of being late because Dana tried to beat him up.

    ~Katt (Caitlyn F.)
    Peace.Love.& Happiness to everyone. :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think Roy did the wrong thing. Even if Dana bullies him it still wasn't to almost get him arrested. He should have been thinking of the golden rule " treat others how you would like to be treated." I think Roy did it to get
    even with him. I think this because he was running towards the Mother Paulas site And Dana got him so he told Dana there was a box of cigarettes in the trailor. Therefor Dana got stuck in the mouse traps a Officer Delinko questioned him.
    Claire

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think that Roy did not not do the right thing because when the police figure out Dana isn't doing the crime at the construction site Dana is going to get out of trouble and try to hurt Roy again. Another reason why i don't think Roy did the right choice is thaqt Roy shounldn't be a bully like Danas is, Roy is just not that type of person to hurt people. i think Roy did it because he was sick of being beated up by Dana pretty much everyday.
    A.S

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think what Roy did was not a good idea because Dana can get Roy back and thats not good for Roy. Roy should not fight back by getting Dana in trouble and he should of left Dana alone so thier is no more problems.
    That is my opinion.
    A.vazquez

    ReplyDelete
  10. I dont think what Roy did was a good thing to do because you should never do something that bad no matter what the circumstances. I think he did that because Dana has done so many bad things to him like pushed him to a window, and almost killed him in the closet.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I dont think it was right for Roy to get Dana in trouble because even though Dana always bullied Roy it wasn't right to get Dana in trouble for something Dana didn't know about. Now Dana's going to kid jail because of that. So now Curly is mad at Dana and Dana is in a lot of trouble. But Dana shouldn't have said he was Roy when he wasn't.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think that getting Dana in trouble might be both a good and bad thing, because Roy was trying to distract the police so he and mullet fingers can save the owls, and when Dana comes back Roy might have an early age funeral.

    Lillian Joyce T.$

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think that what Roy did to Dana was defiantly on purpose and I do not think that he did the right thing by getting Dana arrested! even though Dana would bully Roy that doesn’t mean that he should do it back to him because it always gets more worse and worse and there will be a consequence that Roy will get, like maybe Danas friends will realize what he did to Dana and go after him… also Roy is already beginning to feel guilty that he led Dana to the trailer which he said there were gold gladiator cigarettes inside the trailer.

    ReplyDelete
  14. My opinion on if Roy did the right thing is that he did make the right choice because dana deserved it. roy did it to get Dana back at him for his bullying.

    ReplyDelete
  15. my think that roy did the right thing to get dana in trouble on purpose because dana deserved it. Dana deserved it because of what he did to Roy. Roy did it because he wanted to get back at dana for what he did to him for example he chocked him on the bus, and locked him in the closet and many more.

    - sophie m.-

    ReplyDelete
  16. adding on ..... also its wrong to even tho dana hurt him doesnt mean he should get him arrested and in juvi hall. the answer to each question is both cuz he did it for his own good but also it was wrong to get him in trouble like tht.

    -sophie m.-

    ReplyDelete
  17. oops i did the wrong answer because i was not thinking right. my answer is roy did not do the right thing because no matter what happened roy he should of never got dana in trouble and arrested because its not right to put a kid in jail. i think he did it because he was getting dana back for all tht he did to him.i was thinking of something else.

    sophie m.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think no because it got Dana arested and that not right consoqese Dana got but yet i kinda think yes because he wanted to get back at Dana for bullying hem and to help the owls.

    C.M.T

    ReplyDelete
  19. Yes and No. Yes, beacause Dana had tried to kill(majorly hurt) Roy, so he did deserve it, also it was a decoy, because Mother Pala's All American Pancake House didn't have the E.I.S.,which would have allowed them to bury the owls. No, because Dana didn't actually commit the problems for Mother Paula's All American Pancake House.

    Alexander S.

    ReplyDelete
  20. yes and no because she would ratted him out no she could haved him



    J.N.K.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I personally dont think that Roy did the right thing because Roy has been bullyed by Dana but it gives him no right to get him in trouble. Roy should just talk to Dana and tell him what he feels.
    Carmen

    ReplyDelete
  22. I don't think that roy did the right thin because Roy got bulleyed by Dana a lo t of times but i don't think that he was suppose to get him in trouble fir no reason.

    ReplyDelete